The Appeal of Pools in the Sunshine State

In Florida, having a pool is often seen as a desirable feature, particularly in the St. Petersburg and Tampa areas where the climate is warm and sunny for most of the year. Pools offer a great way to enjoy the outdoors, entertain guests, and cool off during those sweltering summer months.

Impact on Home Value

When it comes to real estate, the return on investment (ROI) for adding a pool can vary. Generally, a pool can boost your home’s value, but the extent to which it does depends on several factors:

1. Local Market Trends: In the St. Petersburg/Tampa area, pools are a popular feature, and homes with pools often attract buyers. However, the impact on value can fluctuate based on current market trends. Homes with well-maintained pools might see a positive effect on value, but the increase might not always be as significant as the initial investment.
2. Neighborhood Norms: The presence of pools in your neighborhood can influence the ROI. In areas where pools are common, a new pool might blend in well and add value. However, in neighborhoods where pools are less prevalent, a pool might not yield as high a return.
3. Pool Type and Quality: The type of pool you install matters. A basic, no-frills pool might not add as much value as a high-end pool with added features like a spa, lighting, or a custom design. Investing in a well-designed and well-maintained pool can improve its impact on your home’s value.
4. Maintenance and Upkeep: Pools require regular maintenance, and prospective buyers might be wary of this additional responsibility. Keeping your pool in excellent condition can help maintain its appeal and value.

Cost vs. Value

On average, the cost of installing a pool can range from $50,000 to $120,000 or more, depending on the size, materials, and features. Studies suggest that, in Florida, a pool might return only a portion of its cost when you sell your home. However, the enjoyment and lifestyle benefits of having a pool can be well worth the investment.

Buying a Home with an Existing Pool vs. Building a New Pool

If you’re considering a pool for your Florida home, you have two main options: buying a property with an existing pool or adding a pool to a new or existing home. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide which route might be best for you:

Buying a Home with an Existing Pool

Pros:

• Immediate Enjoyment: You can start enjoying the pool right away without the hassle of construction.
• Established Value: A home with a pool already has the pool factored into its value. If the pool is well-maintained, it could be a significant draw for buyers and might save you the cost of installing one.
• Potential Cost Savings: Depending on the market, you might find a home with a pool at a price that includes the pool’s value, which can be more cost-effective than installing a new pool.

Cons:

• Condition of the Pool: You’ll need to evaluate the condition of the existing pool. If it’s outdated or requires repairs, you might face unexpected costs.
• Style and Features: You might have to compromise on the pool’s style or features if they don’t match your preferences.

Building a New Pool

Pros:

• Customization: Building a new pool allows you to design it exactly how you want it. You can choose the size, shape, features, and materials that fit your needs and aesthetic.
• Modern Features: New pools can include the latest technology and features, like energy-efficient systems, advanced lighting, and custom designs.
• Potential for Increased Value: A well-designed new pool can enhance your home’s value and appeal, especially if it complements your property and local market trends.

Cons:

• Higher Costs: Installing a new pool can be expensive, and the return on investment might not fully cover the installation costs.
• Construction Time: It takes time to build a pool, which means you’ll have to wait before you can start enjoying it.
• Maintenance Costs: New pools come with ongoing maintenance and upkeep costs, which should be factored into your decision.

Our Personal Experience: Buying vs. Building

My husband and I recently faced the dilemma of whether to buy a home with an existing pool or invest in a property with a large lot where we could build our own pool. It was a challenging decision, and here’s how we navigated it:

Buying a Home with an Existing Pool:

We were tempted by the idea of moving into a home with an existing pool because it promised immediate enjoyment. We could picture ourselves relaxing by the pool on sunny days without the wait and hassle of construction. Plus, having a pool already in place meant that we wouldn’t have to factor in the additional costs of installation.

However, our excitement was tempered by the reality of evaluating each pool’s condition. Many of the homes we considered had older pools that might require significant updates or repairs. Additionally, we found that some of the pools didn’t quite match our ideal vision in terms of design and features.

Building a New Pool:

On the other hand, building a new pool gave us the opportunity to create our perfect backyard oasis. We could choose every detail, from the shape and size of the pool to the inclusion of features like a spa or custom lighting. We were excited about the prospect of designing something that would truly enhance our lifestyle.

Yet, we had to weigh the higher costs and the time it would take to complete the construction. We also considered the ongoing maintenance that comes with a new pool, which added another layer of complexity to our decision.

Ultimately, we decided to purchase a home with a newer existing pool that didn’t require much maintenance and was built to last. We felt this choice struck the right balance between immediate enjoyment and long-term durability. By opting for a home with a newer pool, we avoided the extensive costs and time involved in a full build while ensuring that the pool was in good condition and would serve us well for years to come. This decision allowed us to enjoy the benefits of having a pool without the need for significant updates or repairs.

Final Thoughts

Adding a pool can certainly enhance your enjoyment of your home and offer some potential increase in value. However, it’s crucial to weigh the costs against the potential ROI, whether you’re buying a home with an existing pool or building a new one. Consider your long-term plans, the local market conditions, and how a pool fits into your overall home improvement strategy and lifestyle preferences.

If you’re unsure about how a pool might affect your home’s value or which option is best for you, it’s a good idea to consult with a local real estate professional or appraiser. They can provide insights tailored to the St. Petersburg/Tampa market and help you make an informed decision.

Ultimately, if a pool aligns with your lifestyle and you’re ready for the investment, it could be a fantastic addition to your home. Dive into your plans with a clear understanding, and you’ll be on your way to enjoying the perfect poolside experience in sunny Florida!

Contact one of our experienced appraisers today for more information about the appraisal process, our appraisal services, or to request a quote. You can also check out our Google reviews to see what our satisfied clients have to say.